Canadian ETF comparison

HHIS vs BIGY: U.S. Equity High Income ETF Comparison

HHIS and BIGY both turn large U.S. companies into high income with covered calls and borrowing. HHIS holds 20 Harvest single-stock ETFs, is unhedged and pays monthly. BIGY, Evolve's TSX-listed fund (not a U.S. ETF with the same ticker), holds its stocks directly, borrows up to 33%, is hedged to the Canadian dollar and pays twice a month.

Published · Facts checked

Track HHIS and BIGY income in Yieldello →

Quick comparison

FieldHHISHarvest Diversified High Income Shares ETFBIGYEvolve US Equity UltraYield ETF (TSX: BIGY)
Covered-call approachThrough underlying Harvest single-stock covered-call ETFsActive covered calls on about 50% of its stock portfolio
Geographic focusMainly large U.S. companies, technology-heavyLeading U.S. companies
Holdings20 Harvest single-stock ETFs (October 2026)Direct U.S. stock portfolio; 22 holdings listed (October 2026)
LeverageAbout 25%, mainly inside the underlying ETFsUp to 33% (1.33× exposure)
CurrencyCAD, unhedged (HHIS.U trades in USD)CAD, hedged to the Canadian dollar
DistributionsMonthly (variable)Twice a month
FeesNo fund-level management fee; MER 1.72% with the underlying ETFs' fees, 1.89% with trading costs (first half of 2026)0.40% management fee, plus taxes; MER 0.61%, 2.05% with trading costs (to June 2026)
ProviderHarvest ETFsEvolve ETFs
InceptionJanuary 16, 2025September 9, 2025

Facts from each provider: Harvest ETFs: HHIS, Evolve ETFs: BIGY. Yield and fund size change too often to show here; check the provider before investing.

Key differences

  • Construction: HHIS holds single-stock ETFs, each borrowing and writing calls on one company; BIGY holds its stocks directly and manages calls and leverage across one portfolio.
  • Currency: BIGY is hedged to the Canadian dollar; HHIS's Canadian-dollar units aren't, so U.S.-dollar moves show up in its returns.
  • Borrowing and costs: HHIS borrows about 25% through its underlying ETFs; BIGY permits up to 33%. Total costs are similar (1.89% and 2.05% with trading costs, in their latest reports), but HHIS's are mostly fund fees and BIGY's mostly trading and borrowing costs.
  • Payments: HHIS pays monthly, BIGY twice a month. The schedule doesn't change what you earn in a year, but it matters if you budget from the cash.

Income and distributions

Both pay variable distributions from option premiums, dividends and portfolio results, boosted by borrowing. Amounts can change, and part of a payment can be return of capital rather than income.

Compare the dollars paid over the same months on the same amount invested, not one payment or a quoted yield: BIGY splits its cash across two payment dates, and a single month's rate says little about the year.

What Is Return of Capital (ROC)?Weekly, Twice-Monthly, or Monthly ETF Distributions: Does Payment Frequency Really Matter?

Performance and total return

Both are young: HHIS launched in January 2025 and BIGY in September 2025, so compare them from BIGY's start. Covered calls cap part of the upside in rallies, and borrowing deepens losses in a decline, more so at BIGY's 33% limit.

Currency also separates their results. When the U.S. dollar rises against the Canadian dollar, HHIS gains from it and BIGY doesn't; when it falls, the reverse. Compare total return (price change plus distributions) over the same dates.

Covered Call ETF Total Return: Why Yield Alone Isn't Enough

Underlying exposure

Both centre on the largest U.S. technology and communication companies: Microsoft, NVIDIA, Apple, Amazon, Alphabet, Broadcom, Meta and Tesla are in both. HHIS adds faster-moving names such as Palantir, Robinhood, SoFi and Reddit; BIGY's late-October holdings include Berkshire Hathaway, JPMorgan, Visa, Walmart and ExxonMobil.

Holding both repeats much of the same large-company exposure. BIGY is also one of the three funds inside Evolve's EASY, and HHIS was 40% of Harvest's HONE at launch, so either all-in-one fund adds to it.

HONE vs EASY: All-in-One High Income ETFs ComparedIncome Portfolio Concentration Risk

The bottom line

HHIS may appeal more if…

  • Unhedged U.S.-dollar exposure is a deliberate part of the plan.
  • A basket of separately managed single-stock income strategies, including faster-growing companies, fits the portfolio.
  • Monthly payments suit how you budget.

BIGY may appeal more if…

  • Hedging to the Canadian dollar is preferred.
  • A directly held portfolio with some financial, consumer and energy companies alongside technology fits the intended role.
  • Twice-monthly payments and up to 33% leverage suit the investor.

Compare income ETFs with better context

Yieldello helps DIY income investors track the income their investments generate and understand how that income fits into the bigger picture.

Create a Free Account

This page is for general educational purposes only and is not investment advice. ETF characteristics, distributions, fees, and risks can change over time. Review issuer documents and consider your own circumstances before making investment decisions.