Canadian ETF comparison

ECHI vs CANY: Canadian High Income ETF Comparison

ECHI and CANY both aim for high income from Canadian companies and pay twice a month. ECHI holds Ninepoint HighShares ETFs that manage each company's income strategy. CANY holds stocks directly, with a higher leverage limit and a larger basket of companies.

Published · Facts checked

Track ECHI and CANY income in Yieldello →

Quick comparison

FieldECHINinepoint Enhanced Canadian HighShares ETFCANYEvolve Canadian Equity UltraYield ETF
Covered-call approachThrough single-stock HighShares ETFs; provider lists coverage up to 50% of NAVActive covered calls on about 50% of its stock portfolio
Geographic focusCanadian companies (TSX-listed)Leading Canadian companies
HoldingsHighShares ETFs on 13 Canadian companies (September 2026)Direct Canadian stock portfolio; 20 holdings listed (November 2026)
LeverageUp to 25%, inside the underlying ETFsUp to 33% (1.33× exposure)
CurrencyCADCAD, unhedged
DistributionsTwice a monthTwice a month
FeesNo fund-level management fee; the underlying ETFs charge 0.29%. MER 1.88%, 1.97% with trading costs (first half of 2026)0.40% management fee, plus taxes; MER 0.61%, 2.46% with trading and borrowing costs (first half of 2026)
ProviderNinepoint PartnersEvolve ETFs
InceptionAugust 22, 2025September 17, 2025

Facts from each provider: Ninepoint: ECHI, Evolve ETFs: CANY. Yield and fund size change too often to show here; check the provider before investing.

Key differences

  • Construction: ECHI bundles single-stock HighShares ETFs; CANY selects stocks and manages the call strategy in one portfolio.
  • Borrowing: ECHI's underlying ETFs use up to 25% leverage; CANY permits up to 33%. Extra borrowing increases exposure to both gains and losses.
  • Portfolio size: ECHI provides exposure to 13 companies in its September snapshot; CANY lists 20 holdings in October. The companies and their weights matter alongside the count.

Income and distributions

Payment frequency is a similarity here. Compare total cash paid over matching periods and whether the amount is steady or changing. Both combine dividends with covered-call income; payments can also include return of capital.

ECHI's underlying funds charge a 0.29% management fee, while CANY charges 0.40%. Counting other expenses, trading and borrowing, their costs in the first half of 2026 were 1.97% a year for ECHI and 2.46% for CANY.

Measuring Distribution ConsistencyWhat Is Return of Capital (ROC)?

Performance and total return

ECHI began in August 2025 and CANY in September 2025. Use a shared start date when comparing their provider-reported total returns, which include distributions, rather than comparing since-inception figures with different starting points.

Both have short histories. Covered calls exchange some potential upside for income, while borrowing amplifies market moves. A distribution yield measures the payout relative to price; total return shows how income and changes in value combine.

Covered Call ETF Total Return: Why Yield Alone Isn't Enough

Underlying exposure

For ECHI, look through each HighShares ETF to its underlying company. Ninepoint's September portfolio has substantial energy and financial exposure. CANY's August ETF Facts also show a large financial allocation, with a different mix of companies and weights.

Their published portfolios include shared names such as TD, Royal Bank, Shopify and Cameco. Holding both can repeat those businesses. Check each provider's latest holdings against the Canadian stocks and funds already in the portfolio.

CANY ETF Facts and Holdings SnapshotIncome Portfolio Concentration Risk

The bottom line

ECHI may appeal more if…

  • A basket of separately managed single-stock income strategies fits the portfolio.
  • Its energy and financial exposure and lower leverage limit suit the intended role.

CANY may appeal more if…

  • One directly managed stock portfolio with more holdings is preferred.
  • The additional exposure from its higher borrowing limit fits the investor's risk tolerance.

Compare income ETFs with better context

Yieldello helps DIY income investors track the income their investments generate and understand how that income fits into the bigger picture.

Create a Free Account

This page is for general educational purposes only and is not investment advice. ETF characteristics, distributions, fees, and risks can change over time. Review issuer documents and consider your own circumstances before making investment decisions.