Canadian ETF comparison

CLSA vs HDIV: Split Share vs Covered Call Income

CLSA and HDIV both pay high monthly income by holding other funds, but they get there differently. CLSA holds Class A shares of split share funds, mostly banks and life insurers, which are leveraged by design. HDIV holds Hamilton's covered-call ETFs across several sectors and borrows about 25% more on top.

Published · Facts checked

Track CLSA and HDIV income in Yieldello →

Quick comparison

FieldCLSABrompton Split Corp. Enhanced Equity Income ETFHDIVHamilton Enhanced Canadian Covered Call ETF
Covered-call approachNone at the ETF level; the split funds it holds may write callsThrough underlying Hamilton sector covered-call ETFs (a fund of funds)
Geographic focusMainly Canadian financial companies, through split share fundsMainly Canadian equities, sector mix broadly like the S&P/TSX 60
HoldingsClass A shares of 12 split share funds, led by banks and life insurers (September 2026)10 Hamilton covered-call ETFs, led by Canadian financials and energy (October 2026)
LeverageNo borrowing by the ETF; Class A shares carry the split funds' built-in leverageAbout 25% of its value, through cash borrowing (about 1.25× exposure)
CurrencyCADCAD, not hedged
DistributionsMonthly (variable)Monthly
Fees0.60% management fee, plus the costs inside the split funds it holdsNo fund-level management fee; MER 0.97%, 1.75% with trading costs (first half of 2026)
ProviderBrompton FundsHamilton ETFs
InceptionMarch 20, 2025July 19, 2021

Facts from each provider: Brompton Funds: CLSA, Hamilton ETFs: HDIV. Yield and fund size change too often to show here; check the provider before investing.

Key differences

  • Where the income comes from: HDIV's underlying ETFs earn option premiums and dividends. CLSA's split funds pay Class A holders from dividends left after preferred shareholders are paid, capital gains and, in some funds, call writing.
  • Leverage: HDIV borrows cash for about 1.25× exposure. CLSA doesn't borrow, but a split fund's Class A shares absorb the gains and losses on the preferred shares' portion too, which can be about 2× at the start.
  • Payment risk: a split fund stops paying its Class A holders if its net asset value per unit would fall below a set level, $15 for Brompton's funds. That can reduce CLSA's income quickly in a sharp market fall.

Income and distributions

Neither payment is fixed. CLSA's monthly payment has moved from $0.13 late in 2025 to $0.235 in September 2026 and $0.22 in November 2026. Brompton says Class A payments can combine return of capital, capital gains and dividends, so the amount you keep after tax depends on the mix.

HDIV's payment depends on the option premiums its underlying ETFs earn, less the cost of its borrowing. Compare the dollars each pays on the same investment over the same months, and how the mix is reported on your tax slips.

What Is Return of Capital (ROC)?

Performance and total return

CLSA has only traded since March 2025, so any comparison has to start there, and it hasn't yet been through a long market decline. HDIV has a record back to July 2021.

Both are leveraged, so both can fall faster than the stocks underneath. Split funds don't have to sell stocks to reduce borrowing after a fall, because their leverage comes from preferred shares with set terms. HDIV's cash borrowing is managed around its target. Judge either on total return over matching periods, not yield.

Covered Call ETF Total Return: Why Yield Alone Isn't Enough

Underlying exposure

CLSA is concentrated: in September 2026, Canadian banks, North American financials and Canadian life insurers made up about 68% of the portfolio, with the rest in dividend stocks, energy and infrastructure. HDIV is spread across financials, energy, technology, gold and utilities, though its two financial ETFs (HFIN and HMAX) were still about 44% of its net value in October 2026.

Canadian bank and insurance stocks are common in income portfolios, so either fund can add to a position you already have. On cost, the two aren't reported the same way: CLSA's expense figures include the preferred dividends its split funds pay, which regulators require them to count as a cost, so check each fund's ETF Facts and read what's included before comparing.

Income Portfolio Concentration Risk

The bottom line

CLSA may appeal more if…

  • Leveraged exposure to Canadian financials is a deliberate choice.
  • The risk of a split fund suspending its Class A payments is understood and acceptable.
  • A short track record isn't a concern.

HDIV may appeal more if…

  • Income from several sectors is preferred to a mainly financial portfolio.
  • Option premiums and about 25% borrowing fit the plan better than split share leverage.
  • A longer record to judge it by matters.

Compare income ETFs with better context

Yieldello helps DIY income investors track the income their investments generate and understand how that income fits into the bigger picture.

Create a Free Account

This page is for general educational purposes only and is not investment advice. ETF characteristics, distributions, fees, and risks can change over time. Review issuer documents and consider your own circumstances before making investment decisions.